| — |  | Gummy BearsChewy, colorful, gone by the handful | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Sour WormsSour first, sweet second, painful third | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Milk ChocolateThe safest pick and a strong one | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Caramel ChewsSoft enough to loosen a filling | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | LicoriceThe one that splits every room in half | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Hard CandyTwenty minutes of commitment per piece | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | MarshmallowsAir, sugar, and nothing else | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Peanut Butter CupsSalt and chocolate in the correct ratio | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Jelly BeansHalf the flavors are a gamble | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | ToffeeButtery, brittle, and loud to eat | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Candy CanesOnly allowed out for one month a year | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Cotton CandyEnormous until it touches your tongue | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | LollipopsA sugar sphere on a stick, no rush | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Chocolate TrufflesSoft centre, cocoa dust, gone in one | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | NougatChewy, nutty, and hard to put down | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | FudgeDense enough to count as a meal | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | GumdropsSugar coated jelly in every colour | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Candy CornLoved and hated in equal measure | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Rock CandyCrystals on a string, pure sugar | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | PeppermintsThe sweet at the bottom of every handbag | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | ButterscotchBrown sugar and butter, boiled hard | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Chocolate CoinsFoil wrapped, and never quite good chocolate | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Turkish DelightRose, sugar, and a dusting of starch | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Salt Water TaffyPulled, wrapped, and impossible to eat quietly | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | JawbreakersA candy that lasts longer than you do | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Chocolate Covered AlmondsThe one sweet that pretends to be healthy | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Wine GumsFirm, fruity, and nothing to do with wine | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | MarzipanAlmond paste shaped into anything | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Bubble GumFlavour for four minutes, chewing for forty | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | Dark ChocolateBitter enough to feel like a decision | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | White ChocolateTechnically not chocolate, still winning | — win | — match wins |
| — |  | PralinesCaramelised nuts, cracked into pieces | — win | — match wins |