| 1 |  | PepperoniThe default champion, and it earned that spot | 100% win | 100% match wins |
| 2 |  | PineappleThe topping that starts arguments at every table | 0% win | 80% match wins |
| 3 |  | JalapenosHeat that builds slice after slice | 0% win | 71% match wins |
| 4 |  | Extra CheeseSimply more of the best part | 0% win | 60% match wins |
| 4 |  | SpinachWilted green that lightens the whole slice | 0% win | 60% match wins |
| 6 |  | SausageFennel and fat in every single bite | 0% win | 50% match wins |
| 6 |  | Green PeppersCrunch with a faint bitter edge | 0% win | 50% match wins |
| 8 |  | MushroomsEarthy and meaty, soaks up everything around it | 0% win | 0% match wins |
| 8 |  | BaconSmoky, salty, and always welcome | 0% win | 0% match wins |
| 8 |  | Black OlivesBriny little rings of concentrated salt | 0% win | 0% match wins |
| 8 |  | Red OnionsSharp raw, sweet once they caramelize | 0% win | 0% match wins |
| 8 |  | HamSalty and sweet at the same time | 0% win | 0% match wins |
| 8 |  | AnchoviesDivisive salt bombs straight from the sea | 0% win | 0% match wins |
| — |  | Grilled ChickenMild and filling, safe for absolutely anyone | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | Fresh BasilBright leaves dropped on after the bake | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | RicottaCreamy white clouds tucked between the cheese | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | ProsciuttoAdded after the oven, never before | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | SalamiSpicier, thinner, and slightly curled | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | MeatballsSliced, seasoned, and heavy going | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | ChorizoPaprika oil pooling in every slice | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | ShrimpDivisive on a pizza and worth defending | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | TunaCommon in Europe, alarming elsewhere | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | Artichoke HeartsSoft, tangy, and quietly essential | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | Sun Dried TomatoesConcentrated, chewy, and intensely savoury | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | Roasted GarlicWhole cloves, sweet and mellow | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | ZucchiniThin ribbons that crisp at the edge | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | EggplantGrilled first, or it turns to sponge | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | Sweet CornStandard in Japan and Brazil, odd elsewhere | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | FetaSalty crumbles that never fully melt | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | Goat CheeseTangy, creamy, and slightly barnyard | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | Blue CheeseStrong enough to be the only topping | 0% win | — match wins |
| — |  | Chili FlakesHeat added by the person eating it | 0% win | — match wins |