| 1 |  | Key Lime PieSharp citrus that cuts through the sweetness | 13% win | 71% match wins |
| 2 |  | Waffle ConeThe container that outshines what is inside | 10% win | 61% match wins |
| 3 |  | Carrot CakeSpiced crumb buried under cream cheese frosting | 10% win | 57% match wins |
| 4 |  | ChurrosRidged, sugared, and made for dipping | 10% win | 54% match wins |
| 5 |  | Chocolate CakeDense, dark, and impossible to argue with | 7% win | 75% match wins |
| 6 |  | TiramisuCoffee, cocoa, and cream in soft layers | 7% win | 62% match wins |
| 7 |  | Apple PieWarm spice under a flaky golden lid | 7% win | 53% match wins |
| 8 |  | Bread PuddingStale bread turned into something better | 7% win | 47% match wins |
| 9 |  | Sticky Toffee PuddingDark, warm, and drowning in sauce | 3% win | 67% match wins |
| 10 |  | FlanSet custard under a caramel slick | 3% win | 60% match wins |
| 10 |  | DoughnutsFried dough, glazed, best within the hour | 3% win | 60% match wins |
| 12 |  | BrowniesThe corner piece is a different food entirely | 3% win | 57% match wins |
| 13 |  | Banana PuddingSoft layers that get better overnight | 3% win | 55% match wins |
| 14 |  | Chocolate Chip CookiesBest eaten while the middle is still soft | 3% win | 50% match wins |
| 15 |  | Creme BruleeYou crack the top before you taste anything | 3% win | 44% match wins |
| 16 |  | Ice Cream SundaeBuilt in layers until it stops making sense | 3% win | 38% match wins |
| 17 |  | Panna CottaBarely set cream that wobbles on the spoon | 3% win | 33% match wins |
| 18 |  | Gulab JamunFried dough soaked in rose syrup | 0% win | 67% match wins |
| 19 |  | MochiChewy rice dough around something sweet | 0% win | 60% match wins |
| 20 |  | Mille FeuilleA thousand layers and no clean way to eat it | 0% win | 50% match wins |
| 20 |  | PavlovaCrisp meringue, soft centre, fresh fruit | 0% win | 50% match wins |
| 22 |  | Lemon TartBright curd in a crisp buttery shell | 0% win | 43% match wins |
| 22 |  | EclairsChoux pastry, cream, chocolate lid | 0% win | 43% match wins |
| 22 |  | Black Forest CakeChocolate, cherries and a lot of cream | 0% win | 43% match wins |
| 25 |  | CheesecakeRich enough that one slice is a commitment | 0% win | 33% match wins |
| 25 |  | TrifleLayers of sponge, custard and cream in a bowl | 0% win | 33% match wins |
| 25 |  | Pecan PieSugar, syrup and nuts set into a shell | 0% win | 33% match wins |
| 28 |  | MacaronsFragile shells with a soft middle | 0% win | 20% match wins |
| 28 |  | ProfiterolesA tower of small buns under hot sauce | 0% win | 20% match wins |
| 30 |  | BaklavaLayers, nuts, and far too much honey | 0% win | 0% match wins |
| 30 |  | CannoliCrisp shell filled at the last minute | 0% win | 0% match wins |
| 30 |  | Rice PuddingSlow cooked, nutmeg on top, deeply comforting | 0% win | 0% match wins |